How Gemini recommends products, and how it differs from ChatGPT

Published

By Carson Cobb. Research from November 4 to 11, 2026.

Gemini sits inside Google’s apps, Android phones and Chrome, so it reaches shoppers who never open ChatGPT. I asked it the same 48 shopping questions I asked ChatGPT and Google AI Mode, and compared how it picks.

The short version

  • Gemini names more brands. A median of 5 per answer and up to 12, against 4 and 8 for ChatGPT.
  • It quotes certifications twice as often as ChatGPT. 23 of 48 answers versus 12.
  • It rarely shows prices. 12 of 48 answers, against 38 for ChatGPT.
  • It rarely asks about the shopper. It suggests related topics instead.
  • It gets ratings wrong more than prices. Prices right for 22 of 24 products, ratings for 14 of 23.

Gemini, ChatGPT and AI Mode side by side

MeasureGeminiChatGPTGoogle AI Mode
Brands per answer, median545
Most brands in one answer12811
Different brands across 48 answers254193230
Answers citing certifications231225
Answers citing organic claims16714
Answers showing prices123830
Correct price, specific product22 of 2422 of 2419 of 24
Correct rating, specific product14 of 2317 of 2312 of 22

Sources: how many brands AI recommends, why AI recommends products, prices in AI shopping answers, what AI gets wrong.

What stands out

Gemini behaves like a researcher making a longer list. More brands per answer, more emphasis on certifications and claims, fewer prices. It also agrees with ChatGPT less than you’d think: for a typical question, only 2 brands were named by Gemini, ChatGPT and AI Mode alike (brand overlap).

The longer list is good news for smaller brands. A fifth or sixth slot is a real opening. The weak spot is ratings: Gemini got the rating wrong most often where a review app had added a second copy of the product data, right just 2 times out of 8.

What to do with this

  1. Name your certifications plainly on product pages, with the certifying body.
  2. Use one Product block with your rating in it, so Gemini doesn’t pick the wrong number.
  3. Test Gemini separately. Its list differs from ChatGPT’s.
  4. Make your price easy to find on the product page and in structured data, since Gemini rarely volunteers it.

Testing where Gemini names you is part of my AI Search and Conversion Audit. The AI Visibility Check is a quick first look.

How this was done

  • Questions: 48 shopping questions across supplements, beauty, food and drink, pet, home and apparel, asked in Gemini, ChatGPT and Google AI Mode in fresh sessions, November 4 to 11, 2026.
  • Fact checks: each AI’s stated price and rating compared with 24 product pages.
  • Limits: one run per question per engine, and Gemini changes often.

No store or brand is named in this report.

FAQ

Questions, answered.

How many brands does Gemini recommend?

A median of 5 per shopping answer in my November 2026 tests, with up to 12. That's more than ChatGPT's median of 4. Gemini named 254 different brands across 48 questions.

Does Gemini show prices for products it recommends?

Rarely. Gemini showed prices in 12 of 48 shopping answers (25%), against 38 of 48 for ChatGPT and 30 of 48 for Google AI Mode. When asked about a specific product, it got the price right for 22 of 24.

What reasons does Gemini give for recommending a product?

Specific claims, especially certifications and organic. Gemini cited certifications in 23 of 48 answers, against 12 for ChatGPT, and organic claims in 16.

Does Gemini ask follow up questions when shopping?

Rarely about the shopper. Gemini usually ended answers by suggesting related topics, while ChatGPT asked about the shopper's situation in 18 of 48 answers.

See where you stand in AI search.

Run the free AI Visibility Check. In about a minute you'll see whether ChatGPT recommends you, who it recommends instead, and what's holding you back.