How many brands does AI recommend in a shopping answer?

Published

By Carson Cobb. Data collected November 4 to 11, 2026.

On Google, a shopping search shows ten results, ads and a carousel. In an AI answer, a shopper sees a short list. I counted exactly how short across 144 answers: 48 shopping questions asked in ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Mode.

The short version

  • ChatGPT names a median of 4 brands per answer. Never more than 8.
  • Gemini and Google AI Mode name a median of 5.
  • A typical question has 8 brands in play across the three engines.
  • Only 2 are named by all three. And 5 of 48 questions had no brand in common at all.
  • The lists barely repeat. ChatGPT named 193 different brands, and only 8 appeared in more than one answer.

Brands named per answer

EngineMedianAverageMost in one answerAnswers with no brandDifferent brands across 48 answers
ChatGPT44.283193
Gemini55.5123254
Google AI Mode55.1113230

How much the engines agree

For each questionMedian
Brands named by any engine8
Brands named by all three2

Of the 419 brand and question pairs in the data, 222 (53%) were named by only one engine, 101 by two and 96 (23%) by all three.

By product area

Product areaDifferent brands namedChatGPT medianGemini medianAI Mode medianNamed by all three, median
Supplements413552
Beauty51344.51.5
Food and drink965862
Pet714652
Home614.55.552
Apparel734.565.52

What it means

Four slots is a much smaller shelf than a page of search results. And because the lists barely repeat from question to question, being named for one question says little about the next. A brand that shows up for “best gluten free granola” can be absent for “best granola for kids”.

That’s why I test many question variations, not one. I covered how much wording changes the answer in how question wording changes AI picks, and how stable the top pick is in how often AI recommendations change.

What to do with this

  1. Write down the 20 questions your buyers actually ask. By need, not by your product names.
  2. Ask all three engines. Agreement across them is rare, so one engine’s answer isn’t the picture.
  3. Track which questions you’re in, not a single score.
  4. Go after the questions you’re closest to. Where you’re named by one engine, find what the source behind it says, and earn the same coverage elsewhere.

Testing where AI names you is part of my AI Search and Conversion Audit. The AI Visibility Check is a quick first look.

How this was done

  • Questions: 48 shopping questions, eight each in supplements, beauty, food and drink, pet, home and apparel, written the way shoppers ask.
  • Engines: ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Mode, each in a fresh session, November 4 to 11, 2026.
  • Counting: every brand named in each answer was coded by hand and counted once per answer.
  • Limits: one run per question per engine. Answers vary between runs, so treat the counts as typical, not fixed.

No store or brand is named in this report.

FAQ

Questions, answered.

How many brands does ChatGPT recommend per answer?

A median of 4. In 48 shopping questions I asked in November 2026, ChatGPT named between 0 and 8 brands per answer, 4.2 on average. Gemini named a median of 5 (up to 12) and Google AI Mode a median of 5 (up to 11).

Do ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Mode recommend the same brands?

Partly. For a typical question the three engines named 8 different brands between them, and only 2 were named by all three. Of every brand named for a question, 53% came from just one of the three engines.

Does AI recommend the same brands across different questions?

Rarely. ChatGPT named 193 different brands across 48 answers, and only 8 of them appeared in more than one answer. Each question gets its own short list.

Why does AI sometimes recommend no brands at all?

Some questions get answered with ingredients, methods or product types instead of brands. Each engine gave 3 of 48 answers with no brand named, and they were the same three questions: a skin treatment, a supplement for a life stage, and a drink for focus. None of the three engines named a brand for them.

See where you stand in AI search.

Run the free AI Visibility Check. In about a minute you'll see whether ChatGPT recommends you, who it recommends instead, and what's holding you back.