By Carson Cobb. Data collected November 16, 2026.
“When will it get here?” and “How much is shipping?” are two of the questions that decide a sale. Shoppers ask them on the product page, in the cart, in chat, and now they ask AI.
I read the published shipping policy of 107 Shopify brand stores across six product areas and compared it with the free shipping offer in each store’s announcement bar. 95 had a readable shipping policy.
The short version
- 12 of 107 stores had no readable shipping policy. That’s 11%.
- Only half give a time range. 49 of 95 policies (52%) stated a range of days.
- Order cutoffs are almost never stated. 7 of 95 (7%).
- Tracking is mentioned in only 36%. 34 of 95.
- The banner and the policy often disagree. 33 stores advertised a free shipping threshold in their announcement bar. Only 12 of their shipping policies stated that same threshold.
What shipping policies include
| Policy element | Stores | Share of 95 |
|---|---|---|
| Processing or handling time | 57 | 60% |
| International shipping mentioned | 52 | 55% |
| A time range in days | 49 | 52% |
| Tracking mentioned | 34 | 36% |
| Free shipping threshold stated | 25 | 26% |
| Daily order cutoff time | 7 | 7% |
The gap that matters most is the cutoff. A shopper buying a gift on a Tuesday wants to know whether ordering by 2pm means it ships today. 93% of policies don’t say, so the shopper either guesses or leaves to check a competitor who does.
The average documented cart abandonment rate is 70.22% across 50 studies (cart abandonment statistics).
The ranges stores give
Of the 49 policies with a time range, the upper end of the first range stated was 5 days or less in 30 of them. Some of those ranges describe processing time, not delivery, and many policies never make clear which is which. “Ships in 1 to 3 business days” and “arrives in 1 to 3 business days” are very different promises.
The banner says one thing, the policy another
Free shipping thresholds are the most common message in Shopify announcement bars (see what Shopify announcement bars say). But the policy page often doesn’t back it up.
| Stores advertising a free shipping threshold in the announcement bar | 33 |
|---|---|
| Policy states the same threshold | 12 |
| Policy doesn’t state the threshold | 21 |
I found no store where the two numbers conflicted. The problem is silence. When the policy doesn’t mention the offer, the shopper who checks the policy before buying, and the AI agent that reads it, can’t confirm it. Among the 25 policies that did state a threshold, the median was $59.
Why this matters for AI search
AI agents now read your policies directly. Shopify’s managed agents.md file points shopping agents to each store’s published policies (Shopify). In a 2026 test of 122 Shopify stores by Search Engine Journal, agents handled return windows well, but no store gave a usable answer about shipping cost to a specific city (source).
The fix for both shoppers and AI is the same: put the numbers in writing, in the policy, in a form that can be quoted.
What to do with this
- State processing and delivery separately. “Orders ship within 1 business day. Standard delivery takes 3 to 5 business days.”
- Add a cutoff time. “Orders placed by 2pm Pacific ship the same day.” Only 7% of stores do this, so it’s an easy edge.
- Put your free shipping threshold in the policy. Use the exact number from your banner.
- List your shipping costs. A small table of methods, prices and times answers the question before it’s asked.
- Show the delivery estimate on the product page and in the cart. The policy page is the source of truth, but shoppers decide earlier.
- Keep it current. If you change carriers, thresholds or holiday cutoffs, update the policy the same day.
Shipping, returns and the rest of what shoppers check before buying are part of my AI Search and Conversion Audit. For setting a threshold, see the free shipping threshold calculator.
How this was done
- Stores: 107 Shopify brand stores, 17 to 18 in each of six product areas (supplements, beauty, food and drink, pet, home, apparel), drawn at random from my dataset of 620 Shopify brand stores. Client stores were excluded.
- Policies: each store’s published policy at
/policies/shipping-policy, fetched November 16, 2026. 95 had a readable policy. - Elements: detected from the policy text with keyword rules (for example “cutoff”, “before 2pm”, “tracking”, “processing”), with day ranges read as “X to Y days”. Results were spot checked by hand.
- Announcement bars: the text of each store’s announcement bar on the homepage the same day, read for a free shipping threshold in dollars.
- Limits: a store may state shipping terms elsewhere, such as an FAQ, a help center or the cart. This report covers the published Shopify policy page and the homepage announcement bar.
No store or brand is named in this report.