By Carson Cobb. Data collected November 16, 2026.
Your return policy does two jobs. It’s a reason to buy for the shopper who’s on the fence, and it’s a promise your support team has to keep. Most stores write it once, copy a template, and never look at it again.
So I read the published return policy of 107 Shopify brand stores across supplements, beauty, food and drink, pet, home and apparel. 101 had a readable policy. Here’s what they promise.
The short version
- 30 days is the default. Of 77 policies that stated a window in days, 50 (65%) used exactly 30.
- Only 16 went longer than 30 days. 11 offered less.
- Free returns are rare. 11 of 101 policies (11%) mentioned free returns or a prepaid label.
- Half list things you can’t return. 51 of 101 (50%) named final sale or non returnable items.
- 24 of 101 policies never state a window in days. The shopper has to guess or ask.
- 6 of 107 stores had no readable return policy at all.
How long stores give you
| Return window stated in the policy | Stores | Share of 77 |
|---|---|---|
| 14 days or less | 8 | 10% |
| 15 to 29 days | 3 | 4% |
| Exactly 30 days | 50 | 65% |
| 31 to 60 days | 10 | 13% |
| More than 60 days | 6 | 8% |
The median was 30 days. Supplements and home goods had the most stores going past 30, usually framed as a guarantee (“try it for 60 days”). Food stores were the least likely to state any window, because most don’t accept returns on perishable goods.
That’s the opportunity. When 65% of stores say the same thing, 30 days stops being a reason to buy. A longer window, or a guarantee written in plain words, is one of the cheapest ways to stand out, and it’s easy to test.
What the policies say
| Policy element | Stores | Share of 101 |
|---|---|---|
| Exchanges mentioned | 67 | 66% |
| Final sale or non returnable items | 51 | 50% |
| Guarantee language (money back or satisfaction) | 44 | 44% |
| Conditions on opened or used products | 41 | 41% |
| States a window in days | 77 | 76% |
| Store credit mentioned | 18 | 18% |
| Free returns or prepaid return label | 11 | 11% |
| Restocking fee | 9 | 9% |
Two things stand out. First, 44 stores use guarantee language, but only 11 make returns free. A guarantee the shopper pays to use is a weaker promise than it sounds. Second, the opened product rule is where most support tickets start. In supplements and beauty, “unopened only” means most unhappy customers can’t return anything, and the policy should say so before they buy, not after.
The average documented cart abandonment rate is 70.22% across 50 studies (cart abandonment statistics).
Why this matters for AI search too
AI shopping agents now read store policies directly. When Search Engine Journal tested 122 Shopify stores with an AI agent in 2026, return windows were the one store question agents answered well, while shipping costs and cancellations mostly failed (source). Shopify’s own agent file, agents.md, points agents to your published policies (Shopify).
That means the exact words in your policy are what an AI repeats to a shopper. A policy that never states a number of days, or buries the window in the fourth paragraph, gives AI nothing clear to say. See Every Shopify store now has an agents.md file.
What to do with this
- Put the window in the first sentence. “You have 30 days to return any unopened product” beats three paragraphs of conditions.
- Say what can’t be returned, up front. If opened products or sale items are final, list them in plain words, and show the same rule on those product pages.
- Consider going past 30 days. If your return rate is low, a 60 day window or a guarantee costs little and gives shoppers a reason to choose you over the 65% who offer 30.
- If you use the word guarantee, make it easy to use. A prepaid label or a refund without a return turns a claim into a real promise.
- Use the same numbers everywhere. Your policy page, product pages, FAQ and footer badges should all state the same window.
Return policies, shipping promises and the rest of what shoppers check before buying are part of my AI Search and Conversion Audit.
How this was done
- Stores: 107 Shopify brand stores, 17 to 18 in each of six product areas (supplements, beauty, food and drink, pet, home, apparel), drawn at random from my dataset of 620 US Shopify stores. Client stores were excluded.
- Policies: each store’s published policy at
/policies/refund-policy, fetched November 16, 2026. 101 stores had a readable policy with more than a few lines of text. - Return window: the longest number of days between 7 and 120 stated in the policy. Policies that stated no window were counted separately.
- Policy elements: detected from the policy text with keyword rules (for example “final sale”, “non refundable”, “restocking fee”, “prepaid label”). Results were spot checked by hand.
- Limits: a store can show different terms elsewhere, such as on product pages or in a help center. This report covers only the published Shopify policy page.
No store or brand is named in this report.