By Carson Cobb. Data collected November 16 and 17, 2026.
A checklist is only useful if you know which items actually separate you from everyone else. So next to each check is the share of 617 Shopify brand stores that pass it. Low pass rates are where the opportunity is.
Access
| Check | Pass rate |
|---|---|
| No major AI crawler fully blocked in robots.txt | 99% |
| agents.md responds | 97% |
| agents.md rewritten with your policies and product guidance | 3% |
| llms.txt responds | 98% |
Brand data on the homepage
| Check | Pass rate |
|---|---|
| Organization structured data | 75% |
| Organization data with a description | 30% of those with Organization data |
| Organization data with sameAs profile links | 79% of those with Organization data |
| Exactly one H1 | 54% |
| Meta description under 160 characters | 52% |
Product page structured data
| Check | Pass rate |
|---|---|
| Product structured data | 86% |
| Only one Product block | 79% |
| Structured data parses without errors | 95% |
| Price and availability | 96% and 97% of pages with Product data |
| GTIN | 23% of pages with Product data |
| Variant data with ProductGroup | 23% of pages with Product data |
| Return or shipping terms | 11% of pages with Product data |
Product page content
| Check | Pass rate |
|---|---|
| Mentions shipping | 93% |
| Has FAQ content | 83% |
| Says what it’s made of | 75% |
| Mentions returns | 67% |
| Says who it’s for | 38% |
| Explains how to use it | 31% |
| Mentions testing or certification | 30% |
| Compares options | 25% |
Catalog, images and publishing
| Check | Pass rate |
|---|---|
| Product type on every product | 33% of stores |
| Alt text on every sampled product image | 25% of stores |
| Blog post in the last 90 days | 51% of stores |
What to do first
Skip what you already pass. For most stores the highest value fixes, in order:
- Say who each product is for, and back it with proof. Content AI repeats. (What AI named brands have in common)
- One clean Product block with GTIN and variants. So AI gets the facts right. (GTINs, variants, review apps)
- Return and shipping terms in Merchant Center and structured data. (Policy schema)
- Rewrite agents.md. (Agentic commerce readiness)
- Describe your brand in Organization data. (Organization schema)
- Measure AI traffic. (Analytics and AI traffic)
Running this checklist on your store, and fixing what matters, is my AI Search and Conversion Audit. The AI Visibility Check is a quick first look.
The conversion side of the same work is in the Shopify CRO checklist.
How this was done
- Stores: 617 Shopify brand stores in six product areas: supplements (123), beauty (127), food and drink (154), pet (41), home (76) and apparel (96). This is my full dataset of 620 Shopify brand stores, minus client stores and one store that blocked automated reads.
- When: November 16 and 17, 2026.
- How: robots.txt, agent files, homepage source, the public product feed, and the page source of the first product in each feed, read before JavaScript runs. Content checks are keyword based and show whether a topic is mentioned, not how well.
- Limits: one product page per store, usually a recent product.
No store or brand is named in this report.